Five one-page forms. Copy them into whatever your team already uses.
BECAUSE WE SAW evidence from research (sessions, survey, funnel): WE BELIEVE the change, and who sees it: PRIMARY METRIC one: GUARDRAILS order value / returns / contribution / speed: SMALLEST LIFT worth acting on: % PLANNED SIZE visitors per version: weeks: power: RUNG A/B / holdout / on-off weeks / before-and-after IF IT WINS we will: IF IT LOSES we will: IF IT CAN'T TELL we will: OWNER name, and the date it will be read:
BEFORE "We're testing the site, not you. Please think out loud.
There are no wrong answers, and I won't be able to help."
TASK 1 "You're shopping for [need]. Find something you'd buy."
TASK 2 "Buy it. Stop when you'd have to pay."
TASK 3 "Before buying, find out when it would arrive and how
returns work."
AFTER "What was the most confusing moment?"
"What almost made you leave?"
NOTE Every hesitation over five seconds, every tap on
something that isn't a link, every question asked aloud.
ON THE CONFIRMATION PAGE, OR THE FIRST EMAIL AFTER PURCHASE One question, free text: "What almost stopped you from buying today?" Optional second question, multiple choice: "Where did you first hear about us?" Read every answer weekly. Group them. Count the groups.
DATE | PAGE | CHANGE | RUNG | BRIEF LINK | PLANNED SIZE
| ACTUAL SIZE | SPLIT CHECK | RESULT (WITH RANGE)
| DECISION | WHAT WE LEARNED | OWNER
CHANGE what, where, live date:
METRIC one, decided before the change:
BEFORE WEEKS whole weeks, no promotions:
AFTER WEEKS same length, no promotions:
COMPARISON what the change didn't touch (other device, similar
products):
TRAFFIC MIX CHECK share by channel, before vs after:
LAST YEAR same weeks' change last year:
RESULT change relative to the comparison (ratio), and the
same figure for past periods with no change:
This is one chapter of The Honest Test, which is free and readable in full on a single page with no form in front of it.